The Discarded Coffee Cup

The Discarded Coffee Cup

It was a sunny afternoon in the summer of 1975 when 24-year-old Maria was found dead in her small apartment in a quiet Pennsylvania town. Her aunt and uncle had come to her apartment to exchange recipes, but instead found her lifeless body lying on the floor.

The police were immediately called to the scene. They found a gruesome scene; Maria had multiple stab wounds on her head, neck, and hands. Despite the police’s best efforts, the case quickly went cold.

For nearly 50 years, Maria's murder remained unsolved. But in 2022, the case was reopened, and a breakthrough was made using modern DNA techniques. The police had discovered a DNA sample that they believed belonged to the killer, and after running it through a database, they determined that the suspect was of Italian heritage from a small town in Southern Italy.

The police used genealogy research techniques and followed the genealogy trail of individuals that immigrated from that small town in Italy to the USA and finally to Pennsylvania.  With this information in mind, the police narrowed down their list of suspects to those with small Italian town ancestry in the county where the murder occurred. After an exhaustive investigation, it was determined that there was only one suspect who fit the bill - a man named Richard.

The police began to follow Richard, watching his every move and gathering evidence. They finally got their chance when they followed him to the airport and watched as he threw a coffee cup into the trash. The police retrieved the cup and did a DNA analysis on the sample found on it, which confirmed that it was a match to the DNA found at the crime scene.

Richard was arrested and held for trial. He claimed that he had nothing to do with the murder and that he had never even met Maria, but the DNA evidence was too strong to ignore. The trial was intense, with both the prosecution and defense presenting compelling arguments, but in the end, the jury found Richard guilty of the murder of Maria in 1975.

For Maria's family, the verdict brought a sense of closure that they had been waiting for nearly five decades. While the pain of losing their loved one will never go away, they can now rest easy knowing that justice has been served. And for the police department, the case was a testament to the power of modern technology and the tireless dedication of those who work to solve cold cases.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.